Steelmanning Russell's Teapot
Bertrand Russell was an Englishman active in the fields of philosophy and mathematics in the twentieth-century. He is remembered for pioneering analytical philosophy to counter British idealism and prioritising the logical aspects of mathematics over its numerical aspects. Steelmanning is the opposite of strawmanning; instead of attacking a weak, non-existent caricature of an ideological opponent's argument, a steelmanner improves the opposing argument into its best version and then refutes it, even though the opponent did not argue the steelmanned version. Russell already had an impressive record of being a smart man, and he also made a well-known religion-targeted argument proving the philosophical burden of proof is on the one making claims. The analogy he used is called Russell's teapot, which I will explain and steelman to refute its application to arguments regarding religion. Steelmanning Russell's Teapot Bertrand Russell posited an analogy of him hypothetically clai...